Paul McCarthy Is Selling $200 Chocolate Santas to Fund L.A.’s New Performance Art Museum

Paul McCarthy, with a long gray beard, glasses and a red plaid shirt, stands in a plywood room next to a window looking onto the chocolate mold-spinning machine

Paul McCarthy turned a Chinatown warehouse into a working chocolate factory, and the $200 edible editions it’s selling are helping pay for L.A.’s brand-new Performance Art Museum.

Some museums throw a gala to raise money. This one opened a candy shop. According to Time Out‘s Michael Juliano, Los Angeles artist Paul McCarthy’s “Chocolate Factory” opened Nov. 20 inside the future home of the Performance Art Museum (PAM) in Chinatown, and it doubles as a fundraiser: a limited edition of edible chocolate sculptures at $200 apiece, with the proceeds going to the museum. Time Out summed up the business plan in its headline. The museum is getting funded “by selling chocolate butt plugs.”

Yes, really. The factory comes in two designs: “Santa with Tree Plug,” which shows Santa Claus holding a Christmas tree-shaped butt plug, and “Tree Plug,” the plug on its own.

The factory is the art

According to the Los Angeles Times‘ Jane Horowitz, costumed workers cast an expected 300 to 400 chocolate figures a day, each less than a foot tall. Those aren’t for eating. They spin in a chocolate machine and then join a sculpture that keeps growing through Dec. 26, with McCarthy, 81, regularly adjusting and directing the installation.

Time Out described performers in red double-breasted chef jackets and blond wigs filling molds, tending them on the spinner and cracking open the casts, with the finished pieces set to fill the warehouse “at least to the point that the fire marshal will allow.”

A worker in a red chef jacket and blond wig loads clear chocolate molds onto a large white mold-spinning machine in Paul McCarthy's Chocolate Factory
Image: LAmag

The edible edition pays the bills

The chocolates you can actually buy are made somewhere else. Beverly Hills-based andSons Chocolatiers makes them in a food-grade kitchen using the same McCarthy-designed molds, Time Out reported: 1,500 Santas and 500 plugs in 62% bittersweet dark chocolate. Each one is $200, with free pickup at the museum or $25 to ship anywhere in the country. The Times also put the edition at 2,000 edible pieces, sold at the museum and online, with net proceeds going to PAM ahead of its first performance in January.

Simple math: if the whole edition sells, that’s $400,000 in sales before the cost of chocolate, labor and shipping. For a museum this size, that’s real money. Director Samuel Vasquez told the Times that PAM’s operating budget for the current fiscal year is just under $800,000, and that move-in and renovation cost $250,000, covered by donations from board members and individual donors.

McCarthy, who sits on the board, said he hopes the chocolate gives the museum a financial cushion. He’s seen the other ending. The Box, the downtown gallery founded by his daughter Mara and partly funded by McCarthy, closed earlier this year “as the money ran out,” he told the Times. “Can they [PAM] maintain? Will they get the support?”

A 50-year-old joke that still sells

According to LAmag‘s Nina Kremer, the factory has run twice before, at Maccarone Gallery in New York in 2007 and at Monnaie de Paris, the French mint, in 2014.

The origin story goes back further. Time Out reported that as a student in the 1970s, McCarthy put a butt plug on a chair and called it “Brancusi on a pedestal.” Decades later, while fixing the broken piece, he noticed the plug fit perfectly on the tree of a Santa figurine a friend had given him. He bought his own industrial mold-spinning machine after seeing one in Zurich.

In New York, the gallery became a food-grade facility that sold figurines on site, and McCarthy even pictured a joke franchise, comparing it to McDonald’s, with seasonal versions like a pumpkin for Halloween and a turkey for Thanksgiving, Time Out reported. Paris couldn’t do food-grade production on site, which created the split now used in L.A.: display pieces made in the factory, edible ones made elsewhere to sell.

Paul McCarthy, in a cap and gray beard, talks to a group of visitors beside a plywood wall with a window into the chocolate factory
Image: Time Out

McCarthy says cash was never the point. “It never was about making money,” he told Time Out. “The piece itself is too expensive, the chocolate alone is too expensive.” And the L.A. version runs leaner than the last two. “It doesn’t have the kind of money that the mint has,” he told the Times. “It doesn’t have the backing that New York had. Beauty exists in another way, and you don’t need a bunch of pink flowers.”

Getting in

“I keep saying, what better way to inaugurate a warehouse that was intended to be a factory 120 years ago than with a factory?” Vasquez told Time Out. The museum sits in a 9,000-square-foot space at 109 W. College St. Timed reservations come with a $5 donation, and no one gets turned away for lack of funds. In a statement quoted by LAmag, Vasquez called the show “a special fundraiser on the eve of the museum’s opening.” PAM officially opens Jan. 15 with a suspension piece by Australian performance artist Stelarc, the Times reported.

The takeaway

McCarthy split one idea into two products: an installation that draws the crowd and the press, and an affordable edition with a fixed price, a clear count and shipping that anyone can buy. Pair your show or your big piece with something small people can take home, like prints, multiples or a limited run, and say exactly how many exist and where the money goes. A wild concept gets people in the door, but the $200 thing they can carry out is what pays the rent. And if you’re backing a space you love, plan for the money early. As McCarthy learned with The Box, good art doesn’t keep the lights on by itself.

Image: Los Angeles Times